.
The Tortured Soul of Our Economy |
[Reprinted from the Henry George
News, April, 1967] |
IN THE harsh, real world of power politics, people are not
free to trade, buy or sell, at will on an open market. When they are
obliged to pay more for goods than technical difficulties in
production and distribution would alone dictate, then effort is saved
by some parties in commanding the efforts of others without
exchange. Herein effort is saved, not by going to the market, but
by securing special privileges under legalized violence.
"Economic man goes to the market to save himself effort.
Anti-economic man lobbies in Parliament to save himself effort, by
occasioning effort to others."
Hence a form of value arises which is outside the order of economics,
and which is extra-economic, or political, in nature. As an extra
price which people are obliged to pay it may be termed "value
from obligation" as opposed to "value from production."
Value thus has two components: value from production is the index of
man's domination by matter. Value from obligation is the index of
man's domination by man.
Current prices are thus a combination of value from production and
value from obligations, depending upon the degree of monopoly granted
by legislative restrictions on freedom to trade.
Our civilization is devoted to the destruction of value from
production. New technology is always good news. But it is political
value from obligation that must also be destroyed. And here, indeed,
is the rub, because in most cases Parliaments are concerned not so
much with lowering costs as with maintaining prices. It is in 'the
lowering of costs, the destruction of value and the reduction of price
that the hope of increased living standards for mankind everywhere
must lie.
The economy must have a tortured soul. It must suffer from
schizophrenia when, on the one hand, scientists, sociologists and
engineers are striving to provide facilities to make life easier, and
on the other hand, groups with a vested interest in the maintenance of
prices are continually conniving at law to insure that the cost of
making life easier remains high.
At the root of the matter lies the proposition that economy in effort
is the ultimate, rational, economic human goal.
It is toward the lowering of costs and economy in expenditure of
national resources of manpower and materials, that politicians and
economists, acting not as priests of the existing order but as
prophets of the new, must give their attention.
This being so, they must examine the forms of value-from-obligation
which it lies within their influence or legislative power to destroy.
Chief among these are: the high price of land, high rates of tariff,
and high rates of taxation.
These obviously decrease purchasing power; and since consumers call
the tune - "no demand, no production: no production, no
employment," they contain between them the seeds of slump. All
three may be shown to be values-from-obligation that add to prices.
All three, then, must be dispensed with. The challenge is to show that
this can be done!
|