.
| [Reprinted from the
Henry George News, September, 1957] |
THE money sprite, that fascinating pixy, dances upon the
economic stage of life, exerting an irresistable fascination upon the
hearts of all - all but the plodding student of a free society. But
there is fire in her veins. The sparks that fly from her inscrutable
eyes can ignite the paper stage upon which she may be dancing into a
roaring flame which will destroy all, not only the economically
illiterate but the literate as well.
Surely any sorceress whose dance is so bewitching that she can lure men
into destroying empires, creating dictators, and leveling civilizations
is well worth studying in order that at least a modicum of understanding
of the magic and potency of her charms may be attained. If that suffices
not, let it be remembered that as her mad dance upon the paper stage
approaches a state of abandonment terrifying to behold, the student of
freedom cannot avoid the insistent questioning of his friends who, in
worried perplexity, turn to him as the economic rationalist. What does
her dance mean? Where will it end? Will it consume her? Will it consume
us? Yes, though he does not deign to afford her more than a passing
glance, that perverse creature will not let him alone. The tortured
whisperings of her heart, expressed in her dancing feet, cry out for
understanding.
Understand money? Mere bagatelle - simplicity "itself. What is it
but the most marketable commodity in a community. More exactly, can it
not be said to be an article of wealth which at a particular time and
place is commonly used as a medium of exchange?
Has he caught her now? See how tantalizingly close she is to him. He
has only to stretch out his hand to grasp her. He does, but she smiles
enigmatically, eluding his grasp to dance upon a stage of gold and
paper. And her dance there, how graceful and charming, no riotous
frenzy, lovelier indeed by far than when she danced upon a stage of gold
alone. What is the paper portion of the stage? A substitute for gold -
for money? You send her an order or a promise written on a piece of
paper, and she 'dances more entrancingly than she did before.
And what does the perplexing dance of the audacious sprite of money
mean?
Note well in the early primitive steps of her dance she hardly stirs
from one spot, and the stage, what is it but a composition of every kind
of commodity imaginable - skins, salt, shells, beads, tobacco. But what
difficulties she undergoes. How slowly, how awkwardly she pivots. As the
circle of her dance grows wider, almost imperceptibly a beautiful sheen
of copper suffuses all. The stage indeed is now of copper, and from her
dance have gone the halting, clumsy steps. And now as she vaults from
place to place, the stage shifts to one of shining silver. How poised,
how charming, and how much surer she now is. But what is this compared
to her dance upon a stage of gold. How effortlessly she springs from
corner to corner. Wonder of wonders, with the stage of paper and gold,
her dance reaches such heights of sheer ecstasy, her leaps are of such
beauty, that grace itself appears to be personified. How she thrills and
delights as she pirouettes delicately this way and that in answer to the
demands of her audience directing her from their vantage point of the
marketplace in which they sit. What magic conjures such a dance? What
power holds up such a stage ?
Why, it's private enterprise. Sturdily has he held it up through the
multitudinous changes from a stage of the rawest and crudest of
commodities to a delicately intricate one of gold and paper. Hundreds of
independent, unregulated, private banks has he erected to help him - so
many, indeed, that the fall of one occasions but the merest ripple in
its effects upon the stage. Wearisome times has he had, encumbered as he
is with clipped, sweated and debased coins. Paper assignats, mandats,
Continental currency, sad mementoes of eras when they had so cruelly
entangled him, are at his feet. He has had more than his share of the
vicissitudes of life, but through it all he has persevered. True, he is
not entirely free, caught as he is in a web of semantic chains. His brow
is furrowed as he ponders such mundane problems as is the dollar a
nebulous thing called value, or a certain weight of gold or silver? Yet
he holds up the stage as easily and firmly as the mother, her babe.
But, hark! Hear the rumblings of discord. The stage trembles. Suddenly
the golden portion is blacked out, and the money sprite, try as she
will, cannot dance upon it. It is forbidden. She must dance upon the
paper stage. A paper stage! With what justifiable trepidation does she
tentatively place one foot before the other. It yields. The shock and
fear on her face cause the hearts of all to beat madly. Happy day, it
does not collapse. Though weaker now by far than formerly, it stands,
and the sprite, gaining courage, continues the dance. But what a dance!
Whereas, before, the sprite was an angel of grace, now it seems as
though she has drawn up through her mincing feet the devilish
convulsions of the stage. Her dance once so free, and thus so
beautifully controlled so ecstatically enchanting, so perfect, now has
about it a demoniac quality. Wilder and wilder it becomes, as the floor
erupts and heaves this way and that with the sprite jumping madly from
point to point.
What causes this upheaval? Where is private enterprise? There he is,
but, lackaday, shunted off into a corner. Though reviled and spat upon,
yet how he strains to hold up the floor of the stage. His position has
been pre-empted by the government, by whose imperial command he has been
cast aside. And the hundreds of independent batiks aiding him? All gone,
merged into one centralized, socialized banking system which clumsily
tries to help the government. What long cumbersome lines of rules and
regulations stem from the bank and government, entwining private
enterprise, well nigh throttling him. And monetary experts, ad nauseam,
crawl over the bank, tightening this regulation, tearing that one up,
substituting another. And note the horde of bureaucrats gathered
gleefully around a printing press. From it flows mountains of paper,
growing ever higher, pushing up the floor here, undermining it there.
The whir of the press can be heard mournfully whining its dirge of
coming disaster as the bureaucrats continually turn out banknotes,
bonds, bills, checks. And now, the ceaseless whining of the press
increases at an accelerating tempo, much as the music of a mighty
symphony orchestra rises to a crescendo which reaches to the very
heavens, causing the blood to course madly in your veins as you pant and
sob awaiting the inevitable thunderous crash which roars through the
amphitheater, momentarily sweeping the very breath of life from you,
suspending as it were your very soul upon a thread of liquid music. But
what music! The music of desperation crying out, "Stop me! Stop me!"
as the mountains of paper media reach such heights that the floor
literally jumps up. And as it does, out from the sprite's eyes dart
those evil sparks igniting the whole paper stage into a mighty holocaust
consuming all - centralized bank, experts, politicians - all.
What is the meaning of her dance? Can it be that the whole stage which
her presence seems to fill is purchasing media - that part of the stage,
part of purchasing media, is money itself, a commodity, as gold, and the
other part is money-substitutes, orders or promises to pay money? When
one is sure, then, that the money-substitutes can be redeemed in money,
the magic of exchange reaches heights of efficiency and perfection
almost impossible to conceive.
Is she saying that to appreciate truly the real beauty and significance
of her dance, one must seek out the natural laws that rule her? Is she
revealing that the foundation stone of her stage of paper and gold is
private enterprise - that the underlying postulate is that money, credit
and banking are functions of private enterprise and admit of no
government interference or regulation? Is she telling us that money was
created by the people, quite unconsciously, in order to facilitate
bartering of commodities and services, and that no government aid is
needed - in fact that such aid can only cause harm? And is she saying
that the corollary is that money, credit and banking must be controlled
by the people - not the government - through the mechanism of the free
and un-trammeled marketplace?
What a grand design she puts before us! The stage - purchasing media
-money as well as money-substitutes. The foundation - the postulates of
freedom - non-interference by the government and rule by the people
through the marketplace.
Have we understood the money sprite? Must we? Can we afford not to try?
|