.
| In Memory
of Franz Oppenheimer |
| [Reprinted from the
Henry George News, March, 1953] |
Because of long and intimate association with the basic
sociological principles of Franz Oppenheimer [author of The State],
I wish to express, in a few thoughtful words, some of my recollections
of this deceased friend.
During the eighteen-forties Rudolf Virchow (for whom Oppenheimer in the
course of sociological investigations expressed great admiration)
undertook a thorough study, on the spot, of the hunger-typhoid epidemic
in upper Silesia. Not satisfied, with treating individual cases where
the disease had already broken out, he concentrated his attention on the
social aspects of his task. He wanted to introduce practical methods of
at least mitigating the abnormal life-conditions of the populace, i.e.,
of declaring systematic, all-out war on pauperism, housing shortage,
undernourishment and alcoholism. According to Virchow, disease is simply
life under abnormal conditions. Virchow's genius enabled him to see
straight to the root of all evil and disease. He did not overlook, over
and beyond the individual, the latter's integration with and dependence
upon the society of which he is a part.
Purified Drinking Water Halted Munich's
Plague
Until the advent of Pettenkofer, the celebrated professor of hygiene,
it was the custom in Munich to fight typhus only through treatment of
individual patients. At that time thousands were stricken__and hundreds
died every year in Munich, as the dreaded pestilence claimed its
victims. Pettenkofer attacked this as primarily a social problem, and
when by providing the city with pure drinking water and adequate
sewerage he had cut off the plague at the root, the epidemic simply
disappeared, and ill-famed Munich became a healthy city. Pettenkofer
used to say that to achieve any great sociological improvement, the
level of a whole people's standard of living had to be raised, exactly
as in economics or in culture. "In these words is the incalculable
superiority of sociological or social medicine over that of the
individual very clearly expressed," wrote Oppenheimer, the
congenial physician and sociologist, with Muller-Lyer, in his remarkable
book, The Sociology of Suffering.
Oppenheimer had begun his career as an interne in one of Berlin's worst
slum districts, and often had to stand helpless at the bedside of a
tuberculosis patient. From this apprenticeship in individual therapy
emerged the great social or sociological physician, who not only
recognized the pauperism and terrifying lack of living quarters in the
metropolis, but also laid bare the roots of their origin. Yet far from
being satisfied therewith, he likewise proposed a soverign remedy,
described in some of his many big-calibre books. Oppenheimer was one,
with Virchow, Pettenkofer, and Muller-Lyer, of the immortal pioneers in
social therapy. Let us rejoice in this four-cornered constellation,
precious souvenior of the Germany that was, and is no more.
Recognition Came Late
We should not forget that Oppenheimer was also closely associated with
the famous surgeon Schleich, who when he first described his local
anaesthesia before the Medical Society of Berlin, was jeered at and
roundly ridiculed for his pains; later, he was awarde4 high honors for
his immortal discovery.
Particular mention must also be made of Oppenheimer's extremely
psychological studies in Vol. I of his Sociology, where he
really "digs into" the subject to reveal to us his uncommonly
fine observation of psychological phenomena in both individual and
social fields. Here is also a genealogical table of great value,
enumerating the various psychical steps in the development of the
science -- an outstanding analysis, the importance of which I wish
especially to emphasize. Oppenheimer, following Schopenhauer's
voluntaristic psychology, begins naturally, in his "genealogy,"
with the fundamental concepts of the lack of energy and of its surplus.
Energy here, of course, is used not in a moral sense but only in the
psycho-physical sense of Energetics. With Oppenheimer the "we"
consciousness plays a very remarkable and leading role.
From the psychical department and attitude of the relevant group, and
the intellectual community of which it is a part, manifold mental and
emotional impulses penetrate a given individual consciousness passing
then into the more or less clarified "we" consciousness, which
nevertheless still vibrates smoothly with the "I"
predisposition.
Oppenheimer's remarkable personality is indicated in this
characteristic "sample" from one of his last letters to me in
1941:
"I am determined to hold fast to LIFE, if
necessary with my teeth, until the Powers of nonsense and damnation
are finally beaten to the ground . . . I am always hard at work. You
may rest assured that I will neglect nothing that might open the eyes
of the politicians to what must happen. Perhaps it may help. The
Opposition is powerfully organized and entrenched, and we are so few,
and posses only the good weapons of Truth and Reason. I respect all of
that, in the sense that I do not insult people who believe in it or
think they believe in it, but for me, I refuse to have any part on it."
The great thinker, the kind-hearted, just man, the pure, strong
personality embodied in Franz Oppenheimer has passed the boundary
between Time and Eternity. His works live after him, a fruitful blessing
to posterity.
|