.
Ecclesiasticism and Economics |
[Reprinted from The
Freeman, January, 1939]
|
Startling facts about economic radicalism and religion have been
suppressed for centuries and are only now coming to light. Vital matters
have been concealed by sinister forces operating undercover and making
use of the Christian Church and the Jewish Synagogue to distort the
truth. Neither Synagogue nor Church are blameworthy as institutions; but
they have been manipulated by secular powers interested an exploiting
the masses of the people; and thus have been drawn into unwitting and
unholy partnership with oppression.
Ecclesiasticism Prostituted
For Instance, everybody knows that Russian Christianity was hand in
glove with the Czar and the ground landlords of the Moscovite empire.
The clergy were ignorant of the Bible; and were not even aware that they
were tools of the aristocracy. German Lutheranism, likewise, was under
the control of the "junker" class headed by the late
Hohenzollern dynasty, and could teach nothing contrary to the economic
interest of the secular nobility. The Church of England has been called,
not without reason, "the Tory landed aristocracy at prayer."
Religious Upheaval Today
In these fateful days, when economic problems are coming to a head in
dramatic, world-wide crisis, it is no wonder that religion is entering a
new phase in its evolution. Both Synagogue and Church, in such countries
as Russia and Germany, are being handled with brutality. And on the
other hand, in countries where freedom of thought prevails, and where
there are no publicly supported churches, the story is more peaceful but
no less devastating as the people gradually find out the distinction
between religion, on the one hand, and ecclesiasticism with its rigid
theology on the other.
This profoundly important question is considered from a wholly new
standpoint in my book entitled "God and the Social Process"
which the Editor of
The Freeman has requested me to summarize for readers of this
paper. The book is published by the University of Chicago in connection
with the University of Cambridge, England. The brief space at our
disposal makes necessary a somewhat dogmatic condensation as follows:
Hebrews Note "Line-bred"
The ancient Hebrews of Bible times, instead of being a "line-bred"
nation of one stock, were derived mainly from two parent races which
gradually coalesced in the land of Canaan, or Palestine. One of these
races came as nomads out of the Arabian desert; while the other was in
possession of Canaan long before the desert branch arrived on the stage
of recorded history.
The element already settled in the land was known as Canaanites, or
Amorites, the latter term being preferred. They consisted of local
communities without any national organization, scattered about over the
country in the form of little "city states," each locality
being administered from a fortified town, or burg.
Economic and Religious Aristocracy
These Amorites were divided into two social strata. The upper class was
the governing and proprietary element, established in the walled cities,
and monopolizing the land of the surrounding districts; while under them
was an enslaved class of peasant farmers composing the bulk of the
population.
The aristocrats among the Amorites were known by the ancient,
non-Hebrew term "baal" (plural "baalim"). An
individual of this description was a person who held land as a private
possession in fee simple. In the legal character of baal, or master, he
also owned his cattle, slaves and wives.
The term baal was carried up to the gods of the Amorites. To offer
sacrifice at the altars of the Baal-gods, and to take oath in the name
of Baal, signified that the Amorite religion stood for the prevailing
aristocratic, monopolistic regime. The sale of a piece of land or a
slave by one baal to another baal was made sure by swearing before
witnesses in the name of the divine Baal of the locality in which the
transaction took place.
In other words, the religion of the Amorites followed the pattern of
their economics and sociology. It was an aristocratic cult through and
through, based upon the "rugged individualism" which goes
along with land monopoly and exploitation of the general public. The
divine Baal was merely a celestial enlargement und replica of the human
baal.
Incoming Nomads Democratic
But the other branch of Hebrew ancestry, which entered Canaan from the
Arabian wilderness, had a very different economic and social idea. Being
nomads and shepherds, they were democratic. And like unsettled,
wandering social groups in every part of the world, they believed that
the resources of nature were a divine provision for all, and that the
ground ought not to be monopolized by a single individual or by a class
of individuals. This idea was universal among the Indian tribes of
America before the coming of the English, but was driven out of the
aboriginal American mind by the musketry fire of pious Pilgrims who came
on the Mayflower and other excursion boats.
One Original Clan
The invaders from the Arabian desert had no organization in "twelve
tribes," but consisted of a single group, or horde, which
ultimately became known as "the house of Joseph"; but even
this name was probably not in use at the time of their entrance Into
Canaan.
Crossing the Jordan river, this militant group destroyed the baalim and
the walled city of Jericho; then pouring up into the hill country of
Canaan, they demolished the city of Bethel; and about fifty years later
they completed the conquest of central Palestine by annihilating the
walled city of Shechem and its baalim.
Large Area Seized
The Joseph group had now cleared for itself a large area in the heart
of the hill country, about fifteen hundred square miles in extent. And
so far as this particular district was concerned, the Amorite
baal-aristocracy had been destroyed.
The Josephite element gradually settled down and became a small nation
of shepherds and farmers remaining isolated from the Amorites for
several decades. The soil was regard, not as individual private
property, but as the common possession of kindred clans; not to be
alienated or sold, but held in trust by heads of clans in such a way
that the rights of the humblest individual were sacredly guarded as a
matter of justice, or "mishpat."
Religion Follows Democratic Pattern
The Josephite religion followed this democratic pattern, and came to a
center in the country village of Shiloh, where was located the chief
shrine of a deity called "Yahweh" who symbolized the tribal
democracy in opposition to Baalistic land monopoly. (The name "Jehovah,"
found in modern translations of the Bible, is etymologically impossible.
It was invented by scribes many centuries later, and was unknown to the
Josephites.)
Amorites Beyond Josephite Frontiers
Outside the territory of the house of Joseph, the Amorite master class,
however, continued to hold the large part of Canaan. They had more than
twenty walled cities, including "Jebus," or "Jerusalem";
and these fortified centers were the headquarters of baal-aristocrats
who held the surrounding peasantry in bondage.
Drama of Hebrew History
From such beginnings, the drama of Hebrew history now begins to unroll
before us. The Josephite area steadily increased in population until it
contained about two hundred and fifty thousand souls when the growth of
numbers at length became a threat against the rule of the Amorite
aristocracy in contiguous provinces.
At the same time, the oppressed peasantry in the other parts of Canaan,
stirred by the example of democratic land tenure among the Josephites,
grew restive under the rule of the baal monopolists in the various
fortified cities. An alliance naturally grew lip between the Josephites
and enslaved farmers just north of them in a district known as "Issachar";
and this coalition presently extended further northward, embracing two
other localities called "Naphtali" and "Zebulun."
By combining with the oppressed peasants of these three provinces, the
Josephite militia was able to defeat the army of Baal under the Amorite
General Sisera. Thus, the lower classes of Canaan, beyond the frontiers
of the central Joseph group, were set free from their baalistic
overlords and converted to the worship of Yahweh, the deity of justice,
or "mishpat."
Legends of Ancestors
A nation was now gradually taking shape; and in accordance with
primitive habits of thought, the existence of this newly forming
community had to be explained by genealogical myths.
The original core of the nation was the Joseph horde, or tribe, which
had by this time spread southward giving rise to a freshly split-off
group called "Sons of the South" (Ben Yemen) or "Benjamin,"
the younger brother of Joseph. And since there was no longer any
territory in the central highlands for the expansion of these two
groups, it followed that they were the only sons of their mother.
Maternity is known before paternity in early times; and the name of the
female sheep, or ewe (i.e., rachel) became the connecting link between
Joseph and Benjamin, the only sons of Rachel.
These two Sheep Tribes, then, were a solid group at the basis of the
national evolution. They were the men. of Rachel (perhaps "Ish-ra-chel,"
or by elision, "Israel"). And when they entered into alliance
with the oppressed farmers of Issachar, Naphtali, and Zebulun, a further
growth of genealogy was demanded. A shadowy patriarch how began to loom
before the imagination whose name was hot at first agreed upon. His
favorite wife, however, was Rachel, the mother of the two Sheep Tribes;
while all the remaining tribes were born upon a lower level of prestige,
being the sons of slave girls (Bilhah and Zilpah), and of an ugly and
hated wife Leah.
Hebrew Kingdom Appears
Pressure of enemies from outside of Canaan forced the organization of a
monarchy under the Josephite king Saul, and later under David the
creator of a new tribe still further south under the name "Judah"
which was a part of the Hebrew nation for only about seventy-five years.
The Jewish dynasty of David 'became so arrogant and oppressive that the
Joseph tribes and their northern allies withdrew and set up another
kingdom which properly made use of the name "Israel."
The alien tribe of Judah, which had been forced into union with the
Joseph tribes by David, was now traced to the hated mother Leah, who, by
deceit, had been forced upon the lover of Rachel. In other words, the
developing Hebrew mythology followed the pattern of Hebrew history just
as the religion followed the pattern of economics and sociology.
In the meanwhile, the heavy pressure of war taxation and the growth of
indebtedness among the lesser land-holders led to the seizure of land by
creditors; and in this way a newly rich class began to arise which
reproduced the economic status of the old Amorite aristocracy.
Yahweh Becomes "Baal"
Concentration of land in the grasp of a wealthy class, and the
resulting change of property titles from the primitive tribal status to
the commercialistic "baal-tenure," produced a revolution. The
big landlords controlled the government, appointed the priests, and
altered the religious rites. The tribal democracy, which the house of
Joseph had established in central Canaan, was overwhelmed in a vast
resurgence of the old Amorite cults; and thus Yahweh was transformed
into a Canaanite Baal.
Hebrew Prophets
It was under these economic and sociological conditions that the Hebrew
prophets became a factor of high importance on the stage of history.
There were two schools, or groups, of prophets. One school was allied
with the rich and stood for the prevailing social order; it prophesied
in the name of Baal, or of a Baalized Yahweh. The other school was
against the prevailing social order; it denounced Baalism, and pointed
out that the worship of Yahweh was originally identified with "mishpat"
and collective rights to the land.
Between the claims of contending prophets, masses of the people were
uncertain and confused. The ship of state moved rudderless through
stormy seas. The Josephiite kingdom was destroyed by the Assyrian
empire; and then, later on, the tribe, or kingdom, of Judah was broken
up, and its principal inhabitants carried away captive to Babylon.
Judaic Monotheism
The Josephiites disappeared from history (the "lost tribes");
and the Jews thus became the surviving remnant of the Hebrew people.
They carried with them to Babylon certain historical and prophetical
writings which later became the basis of the Hebrew Bible. Ceasing to
call Yahweh by the name of Baal, the Jews instead made use of the term "Adon"
(lord); and the religion came to center about a formula known as "The
Shema," which reads as follows: "Listen Israel! Thy Adon, our
God, is One Adon."
The Synagogue is entirely a post-Babylonian development. Under its
rule, the Jewish masses looked back upon the Hebrew past through a haze
of myth and legend abounding in miracles and obscuring the sociological
and economic facts of history.
While the Synagogue and its monotheistic religion marked a cultural
advantage, the old social problems reappeared, leading to a revival of
prophetism under the lead of Jesus, giving rise to Christianity, which
was really an outgrowth of the earlier Hebraism and not a branch of the
Jewish religion.
Economics and Ecceleslastlcism
On the whole, the influence of both Synagogue and Church through the
ages has been to obscure the very problem which gave rise to the great
struggle of religions under, the Hebrew prophets. This doubtless has
been unavoidable, since the interpretation of Hebrew history and the
Bible is not an easy matter.
But the result has been to make organized religion serviceable to the "vested
interests" which do not want the problem of economics to be raised
or discussed. Yet the great social awakening of today puts pressure upon
Jews and Christians alike to decide what attitude modern religion is to
take with reference to the very problems that agitated the Hebrew
prophets.
|